Emmett's on Grove

What groups say

Groups mostly book tables for birthdays and friend dinners, sharing thin-crust square-cut pizzas and appetizers in a loud, busy room.

• One reviewer hosted an 18-person birthday and described the team as easy to work with. Parties of 5 to 7 are common in other reviews.
• Ordering is a la carte and built for sharing: square-cut pizzas, meatballs, pigs in a blanket, salads and pasta.
• Reservations are hard to get at peak hours; several reviewers mention table time limits and full-party seating rules.
• One party of 5 reported a plate fee for an outside birthday cake.

Drawn from 25 Google reviews of Emmett's on Grove that mention a group, a private room or a celebration, read September 2026. The reviews below describe a group visit, private rooms and larger events first, with the critical ones kept in.

• birthday party, party of 18

  Had a birthday party here with 18 people - the Emmetts team was extremely nice and easy to work with. Food was excellent and everyone had a great time.

• birthday dinner, party of 5

  I had a birthday dinner last night and the services was absolutely ridiculous, I had a slow inattentive, waiter, who had a nasty attitude. If you plan on having a birthday, please do not come here. There’s no room for a party of five or more, tables are too cramped and there is no space for me and my guys to move. Food was over price and decent and if do you plan on bringing your own birthday cake? Just know there is a fee just for plates. For my party if 5 I was charge a plate fee because I asked for plates. The sassy waiter took my cake immediately, without giving me the chance to take photos. PLEASE DO NOT COME HERE!!!!!

• friends group dinner

  I’m a regular here but I had an incredibly terrible experience last Sunday. I decided to bring a group of friends who had been visiting and we were rushed from the start. I get time limits but when the food comes out late and we weren’t able to finish our drinks that’s where I draw the line. Especially when someone comes to tell us it’s time to leave. Completely inappropriate. I won’t be back any time soon.

• group dinner

  The hostess, Hannah, was fantastic and made our whole visit something beyond our expectations. She greeted us warmly as we all walked in and made sure our table was ready, since we already had a reservation. She made sure our server was also attentive and came right to our table. She is the coolest hostess I've ever met. We had two servers who were also both truly attentive, friendly, prompt, and accurate. The pacing of the meal was relaxed, not rushed, and not delayed. The service and staff here make the experience "next level." We ordered the pigs in a blanket, Greek salad, and meatballs for appetizers. Each was outstanding and perfect for sharing. The pigs in a blanket are larger than what you would expect and the wrap was flaky and seeded. Dipped in the mustard, it was better than any wedding I've ever attended (and that's no joke as they are always the first thing to deplete at weddings for a good reason). The meatballs were an unexpected hit. They were very well cooked, but not dry at all. The sauce was flavorful and not overwhelming, so the meatball itself was the focus of the bite. The Greek salad didn't actually include salad, which was perfect, so the fresh tomato, the ideal "baby bear" feta - not too hard, not too soft, the onion, and the cucumber were the focus. The dressing was lightly applied so as to not be overwhelming. The pizza came out before the pasta. The pizza is Chicago-style, so it is thin crust and cut into single-bite squares, and excellent for sharing. The "Hot girl" pizza was the hit. I can tolerate a lot of spice, and this was spicy. I loved it. Pepperoni, jalapeño, and Mike's Hot Honey. It was legit. The other half was Mona Lisa, which was nice, but not in the class of "Hot Girl." The pappardelle bolognese had the right amount of sauce and was prepared perfectly al dente. The noodles were super long and it was like a pasta clown car when you try to serve it. The noddle just kept on coming and eventually had to be cut. The Cacio e Pepe also was a hit with the group, but not my thing. It's more like an "al fredo." The surprise at the end was the key lime pie which had a very strong lime flavor and ridiculously crumbly and chewy crust, topped with a light whipped cream that didn't drown the pie like some do. The pie center had a perfect texture that was creamy and thick, but not viscous at all. The atmosphere was very trendy with great art strewn throughout and 20th century memorabilia also scattered around, like an old 7-up sign or the rotating Schlitz globe. The Globe is apropos as it is mounted outside the restrooms - just in case you need to take a "Schlitz," I guess. There is great natural light in the rear dining room from a skylight and a display of wine racks in the wall. The bar had a well-curated selection for all levels of palates. I had an IPA on tap with the meal and it was a perfect pairing with the spicy pizza. Overall, this is one of my favorite restaurants now, between the service, the ambiance, and the food, Emmet's on Grove is a "must-see" if you're anywhere in NYC.

• friends dinner, party of 7

  The pizza is great but it’s definitely not for everyone. It’s extremely thin crust and they put semolina on the bottom to make it extra crispy - I liked it, but to some people it just makes it taste like a cracker. Their pizza topping combinations are very unique - you have to try the hot papi or hot girl (we liked hot papi more). Also, their pizza does not reheat well (likely because of the crust) so if you want leftovers please skip that and order a reasonable amount. Don’t overestimate how much pizza you can eat - we ordered 4 for 7 people (with no other mains) and we could only finish half of what we ordered (and we are not influencers on diets) so do with that information what you will. The waitress actually did warn us to order only 2 pizzas but we didn’t listen to her so it’s not the restaurants fault 🤷🏻‍♀️ The main reason this is a 4 instead of a 5 though is the ambience. If you want to hear the person next to you talk please skip. The front room is so loud and chaotic with everyone waiting for their reservations (your entire party has to be there and there’s a strict table time limit bc it’s so popular - not the restaurant’s fault it’s just a popular place). And in the back room, the music is so loud, you can’t hear yourself think. Definitely not good for a date but come here with friends who want a cute dinner with unique pizza

Good to know

Sophisticated hangout dispensing boozy drinks & Italian plates, including Chicago-inspired pizzas.

Hours, spend and amenities from Google. Private event hours and minimums are set by the restaurant.

Frequently asked questions

Does Emmett's on Grove have a private dining room?

Yes. Emmett's on Grove offers a private dining room for groups and is available for a full buyout, in West Village. Party table 8-12; dining room 30-65; corner bar up to 20; full venue 50-100.

How much does it cost to book a private event at Emmett's on Grove?

Emmett's on Grove sits in the $$ price bracket for West Village. A private room is usually booked on a food and beverage minimum that scales from that per-head figure, and a full buyout is priced on the restaurant's expected revenue for the night. Minimums run higher on Friday and Saturday nights and through December. Contact Emmett's on Grove for the current minimum and deposit terms.

When is Emmett's on Grove open?

Emmett's on Grove is open Monday and Tuesday 5:00 to 11:00 PM, Wednesday and Thursday 5:00 PM to 12:00 AM, Friday 12:00 PM to 1:00 AM, Saturday 11:00 AM to 1:00 AM, and Sunday 11:00 AM to 11:00 PM, serving brunch, lunch and dinner. The restaurant takes reservations for regular tables. Private rooms can often be booked outside these hours, including daytime events, so ask when you inquire.

What kind of restaurant is Emmett's on Grove?

Emmett's on Grove is a $$ Pizza restaurant in West Village, New York City, rated 4.3 stars across 426 Google reviews. Google describes it as: Sophisticated hangout dispensing boozy drinks & Italian plates, including Chicago-inspired pizzas. It has a wheelchair accessible entrance.

What do guests say about group dining at Emmett's on Grove?

Groups mostly book tables for birthdays and friend dinners, sharing thin-crust square-cut pizzas and appetizers in a loud, busy room. One reviewer hosted an 18-person birthday and described the team as easy to work with. Parties of 5 to 7 are common in other reviews. Ordering is a la carte and built for sharing: square-cut pizzas, meatballs, pigs in a blanket, salads and pasta. Reservations are hard to get at peak hours; several reviewers mention table time limits and full-party seating rules. One party of 5 reported a plate fee for an outside birthday cake. Reviewers praise: staff handled an 18-person birthday smoothly; shareable square-cut pizzas and apps suit a table; birthday candles, surprise desserts and warm hosts; relaxed pacing reported by one larger group. Watch for: very loud dining room; hard to hear across the table; table time limits and rushed turns reported by groups; tables cramped for parties of 5 or more. Based on 25 Google reviews of Emmett's on Grove that mention a group, a private room or a celebration.

Can you buy out Emmett's on Grove for a private event?

Yes. Emmett's on Grove can be reserved as a full buyout, meaning your event takes over the entire venue with no other guests. Party table 8-12; dining room 30-65; corner bar up to 20; full venue 50-100. Regular service runs Monday and Tuesday 5:00 to 11:00 PM, Wednesday and Thursday 5:00 PM to 12:00 AM, Friday 12:00 PM to 1:00 AM, Saturday 11:00 AM to 1:00 AM, and Sunday 11:00 AM to 11:00 PM, so a buyout on a busy night carries the highest minimum.

Keep exploring