Sartiano's

What groups say

Groups mostly book regular dining room tables for birthdays, ordering a la carte across the menu rather than using set menus.

• Reviewers describe parties of 6 to 9 seated in the main dining room; one mentions a downstairs banquette area with exposed brick and arches.
• Birthday groups report the maitre d' arranging complimentary welcome drinks, light bites and a card when notified in advance.
• Ordering is a la carte, with groups sharing focaccia, meatballs, caviar cannoli and pastas; one party of 3 reported a $150 caviar supplement.
• Several reviewers flagged table placement near the host stand, stairs or bar as a problem for celebrations.

Drawn from 26 Google reviews of Sartiano's that mention a group, a private room or a celebration, read September 2026. The reviews below describe a group visit, private rooms and larger events first, with the critical ones kept in.

• birthday dinner

  I can’t say enough good things about this restaurant. I’ve eaten here a lot but they really went above and beyond for my mom and her best friends birthday. We were greeted with complimentary drinks and light bites alone with a birthday card. every single thing we ordered was delicious. Her friends could not stop raving about the food (especially the lemon spaghetti special and the meatballs). Alyssa the maitre D was so fabulous helping set everything up for this evening. Robert was also amazing!!! Thank you so much to sartianos for executing a perfect dinner for my very hard to please mom and her friends lol. If anyone is wondering what to order - the focaccia, caviar cannolis, burrata, fusilli, lemon pasta are 100/10. Everything on the menu is amazing

• birthday dinner, party of 9

  Updating to reflect that management reached out and completely resolved the issue. A+ service. Original: Our server, Junior, didn’t miss a single opportunity to pad the bill. Have dined here many times in the past and had great experiences, but came for a birthday dinner with 8 friends last night and will not be returning. He added a multitude of items to the bill, thinking we wouldn’t check the receipt. Upon confronting him, he tried to convince us that we asked for the excess. Then he said he gave us a couple free items like bread as if it evens out to defend his surcharges. Shocking behavior. Have never experienced this anywhere in NYC before, and especially unexpected for a restaurant like Sartiano’s. Shame because it was one of my favorite Italian restaurants in the city.

• birthday dinner

  Sartiano’s has become a tradition for me and my girls - we try to come at least every three months (sometimes more!) and it never disappoints. The Dirty Umami Martini is hands down the best martini we’ve ever had in our lives. I even celebrated my birthday here, and it was perfect! :D We always bring friends visiting New York too! Charlotte is an incredible server - so friendly, welcoming, and she even remembered us, which means a lot in a city like New York with so many faces to keep track of. That personal touch makes every visit feel special. Every dish is consistently amazing, but the House-Made Focaccia is a must-try (you’ll honestly die, it’s that good). Their gluten-free options are also excellent - thoughtful and delicious. Sartiano’s is one of those rare spots that feels both special and reliable. Every visit is memorable. Highly recommend!

• family group dinner, party of 6

  Warm, cozy yet energetic upscale Italian in NYC. We were traveling thru with a party of 6, and will definitely stop back by when we are there again. One set back is there is no kids menu, not even choices per our waiter, so the 9yr old traveling with us had to opt for a $50 entree. Not ideal, but still ok. I should’ve researched that in advance. Still a solid choice.

• birthday dinner

  I had a sweet and sour birthday dinner experience with Sartianos maître d’ Chris. As a New Yorker, I flew in from Texas to celebrate my birthday with my friends and loved ones. From the moment we arrived, the maître d’ Chris, who should take notes from the fabulous one at the Polo Bar, was dismissive and completely unhelpful. I tell you, it’s your own people. As an African American woman, I thought he would be sympathetic toward me after telling him it was my birthday. The day prior, I went to The Corner Store, one of the hardest reservations to get in town, and had an amazing time. So, to come here and experience this horrible service from Chris was not pleasant. A white woman went to voice a concern to him, and immediately he assisted. I was so offended. My friend, a female lawyer at a prestigious law firm, was also dismissed by Chris. We asked to move our table because it was placed right next to the bar, but he refused to assist and made no effort to accommodate us, even though it was a special occasion. Because of the terrible seating choice, a drink from the bar area spilled onto my friend’s suede jacket—which is completely unacceptable. To make matters worse, as a guest was leaving the restaurant, he literally handed my friend a menu and said, “This is a bad table,” confirming exactly what we had complained about. Thankfully, a female manager assisted me after I told her everything that was happening at my table, and she moved us. Overall, the lack of courtesy, poor seating, and total disregard for our experience almost ruined what should have been a celebratory night—had it not been for the female manager’s assistance. I would not recommend approaching Chris for anything, and I’m not sure if his title suits him.

Good to know

Hours, spend and amenities from Google. Private event hours and minimums are set by the restaurant.

Frequently asked questions

Does Sartiano's have a private dining room?

Yes. Sartiano's offers a private dining room for groups and is available for a full buyout, in SoHo. Private dining and full venue buyout available; multiple NYC locations.

How much does it cost to book a private event at Sartiano's?

Guests at Sartiano's typically spend $100+ per person on a regular visit, according to Google, before drinks and tip. A private room is usually booked on a food and beverage minimum that scales from that per-head figure, and a full buyout is priced on the restaurant's expected revenue for the night. Minimums run higher on Friday and Saturday nights and through December. Contact Sartiano's for the current minimum and deposit terms.

When is Sartiano's open?

Sartiano's is open Monday to Saturday 7:00 AM to 10:30 PM, and Sunday 7:00 AM to 9:00 PM, serving brunch, lunch and dinner. The restaurant takes reservations for regular tables. Private rooms can often be booked outside these hours, including daytime events, so ask when you inquire.

What kind of restaurant is Sartiano's?

Sartiano's is a $$$$ Italian restaurant in SoHo, New York City, rated 4.4 stars across 378 Google reviews. It has outdoor seating and a wheelchair accessible entrance.

What do guests say about group dining at Sartiano's?

Groups mostly book regular dining room tables for birthdays, ordering a la carte across the menu rather than using set menus. Reviewers describe parties of 6 to 9 seated in the main dining room; one mentions a downstairs banquette area with exposed brick and arches. Birthday groups report the maitre d' arranging complimentary welcome drinks, light bites and a card when notified in advance. Ordering is a la carte, with groups sharing focaccia, meatballs, caviar cannoli and pastas; one party of 3 reported a $150 caviar supplement. Several reviewers flagged table placement near the host stand, stairs or bar as a problem for celebrations. Reviewers praise: staff set up birthday extras like welcome drinks and cards; attentive, knowledgeable servers with strong menu recommendations; shareable dishes work well for a table trying the menu; management follows up and resolves complaints. Watch for: tables near host stand, stairs or bathrooms disappoint celebration groups; servers not always upfront about supplement pricing; billing errors reported; no kids menu; children pay full entree prices. Based on 26 Google reviews of Sartiano's that mention a group, a private room or a celebration.

Can you buy out Sartiano's for a private event?

Yes. Sartiano's can be reserved as a full buyout, meaning your event takes over the entire venue with no other guests. Private dining and full venue buyout available; multiple NYC locations. Regular service runs Monday to Saturday 7:00 AM to 10:30 PM, and Sunday 7:00 AM to 9:00 PM, so a buyout on a busy night carries the highest minimum.

Keep exploring