Quality Italian

What groups say

Groups book the private event rooms for milestone birthdays and office parties, with large tables also used for family and work dinners.

• Reviewers describe private event rooms used for parties of about 30, with an on-site coordinator handling planning and menu details.
• One host reports the room allowed a slideshow on a brought-in monitor and Spotify music through the space.
• Large groups report prix fixe and family style formats, plus a $60 restaurant week menu on a big-group visit.
• The dining rooms are on the second floor and reviewers say most tables are set up for larger parties.

Drawn from 70 Google reviews of Quality Italian that mention a group, a private room or a celebration, read September 2026. The reviews below describe a group visit, private rooms and larger events first, with the critical ones kept in.

• private birthday party, party of 30

  10/10! I recently hosted a small (30 people) private party in one of the event rooms for my mom’s 80th birthday. Matt was the party coordinator and he did an all around outstanding job helping us to plan a beautiful event. He was responsive, flexible, and a pleasure to work with! The food was delicious and plentiful, and the staff at the event were friendly, available, helpful, and extremely professional. I also highly recommend the local florist Rosa Rosa for floral arrangements on the tables. Matt worked with my aunt (before the event) to set up a slide show (she brought and set up the computer monitor). My brother was able to stream and play curated music via a playlist on Spotify. The last hour turned into a dance party! Highly recommend for anyone who wants to host a private event. My favorite foods of the night were the filet mignon, crème brûlée corn, fried calamari, meatballs and the tiramisu dessert. We will have to go back to try the chicken parmesan pizza!

• birthday group dinner, party of 20

  It took me over a month to write this review because of how disappointed I have been from this restaurant. Booked a party of 20 people. Went through over 10 email chains of explaining please do not add pork in the pre-fix dishes I am selecting. The restaurant acknowledged that. Then about 20 people show up for a 830pm reservation get seated at 850. And you order your app, and fried calamari has bacon bites all over it & not realizing you take a couple bites to realize there is bacon all over the calamari. First off- who puts bacon on calamari? Second- how the heck do you not advise your culinary staff. I don’t eat pork due to my personal beliefs, but has I been allergic this restaurant would have killed me! A birthday celebration all ruined! That about 20 people got up and left and didn’t want to even eat. Not only that at 1040pm the entrees had just started coming out. Which was after we all started to get up, since we decided not to stay there any minute longer. Didn’t even get to order a second round of drinks. Not only that - it wasn’t until I emailed the restaurant about the situation they cared to talk about it. Till the date, the restaurant has failed to even reach out to me after speaking to multiple people upon making the booking. So when a customer wants to make a reservation 6 people will answer and when they mess up BIG TIME, not a single call came my way until I reached out. PATHETIC!

• office party

  Had an office party there in a private room. The staff was amazing. The food was so good. I highly recommend.

• private room birthday

  We had a birthday party in their private room, and it was absolutely amazing. Top notch service and the food was outstanding. The staff were great and extremely attentive. Would love to try the regular dining area next time we return.

• group dinner, party of 9

  The service and food were amazing! We had a party of nine, and the waitresses were super attentive - everything came out smoothly, course after course Our favorites: Starters – stracciatella and prosciutto Pasta – lobster and truffle And the chicken parm pizza 😋 The interior is great, the restaurant has several rooms, and all the tables are set up for large groups

Good to know

Steakhouse with striking, contemporary design, plus an upmarket menu of chops & Italian fare.

Hours, spend and amenities from Google. Private event hours and minimums are set by the restaurant.

Frequently asked questions

Does Quality Italian have a private dining room?

Yes. Quality Italian offers a private dining room for groups in Midtown West. The 57 Room (up to 32); The Trophy Room (up to 60); combinable.

How much does it cost to book a private event at Quality Italian?

Quality Italian sits in the $$$$ price bracket for Midtown West. A private room or group booking is usually priced on a food and beverage minimum that scales from that per-head figure rather than a flat room fee. Minimums run higher on Friday and Saturday nights and through December. Contact Quality Italian for the current minimum and deposit terms.

When is Quality Italian open?

Quality Italian is open Monday to Friday 11:30 AM to 3:00 PM, 5:00 to 11:00 PM, and Saturday and Sunday 12:00 to 3:00 PM, 5:00 to 11:00 PM, serving brunch, lunch and dinner. The restaurant takes reservations for regular tables. Private rooms can often be booked outside these hours, including daytime events, so ask when you inquire.

What kind of restaurant is Quality Italian?

Quality Italian is a $$$$ Italian-American restaurant in Midtown West, New York City, rated 4.4 stars across 2,994 Google reviews. Google describes it as: Steakhouse with striking, contemporary design, plus an upmarket menu of chops & Italian fare. It has a wheelchair accessible entrance.

What do guests say about group dining at Quality Italian?

Groups book the private event rooms for milestone birthdays and office parties, with large tables also used for family and work dinners. Reviewers describe private event rooms used for parties of about 30, with an on-site coordinator handling planning and menu details. One host reports the room allowed a slideshow on a brought-in monitor and Spotify music through the space. Large groups report prix fixe and family style formats, plus a $60 restaurant week menu on a big-group visit. The dining rooms are on the second floor and reviewers say most tables are set up for larger parties. Reviewers praise: event coordinator described as responsive and flexible for planning; attentive service across courses for parties of 9 and larger; private room food called plentiful and outstanding; shareable signatures like chicken parm pizza feed a table. Watch for: reported dietary restrictions missed on a 20 person prix fixe; long waits past reservation time and slow entree pacing for groups; noise carries into the private room and main floor is loud. Based on 70 Google reviews of Quality Italian that mention a group, a private room or a celebration.

Keep exploring